Francia, equo compenso mitigato

Eccezione accolta per i dispositivi destinati alle aziende. Accolto il principio europeo: il compenso per copia privata non può essere un prelievo indiscriminato

Roma – Il Consiglio di Stato francese ha dichiarato illegittima la disciplina in materia di equo compenso per copia privata: ha così accolto le tesi di una serie di aziende e associazioni francesi tra cui Motorola, Sony-Ericsson, Packard Bell, Nokia e Canal Plus e la visione in materia espressa lo scorso ottobre dalla Corte di Giustizia europea.

La normativa, recentemente introdotta in Francia e al centro del dibattito europeo , era già stata condannata da una sentenza della Corte di Giustizia dell’Unione Europea. Le era stato rinviato in via pregiudiziale il caso spagnolo Padawan SL e le si chiedeva se il diritto all’equo compenso potesse costituire un prelievo indiscriminato su tutti i dispositivi , accorpati solo sulla base della loro teorica utilizzazione per copia privata, o non fosse al contrario da legare all’effettivo utilizzo tecnico e commerciale del dispositivo considerato.

La sentenza emessa lo scorso 17 giugno dal Consiglio di Stato francese riprende proprio le considerazioni espresse in quella occasione dalla Corte europea: ribadisce così il fatto che non basta che un dispositivo sia teoricamente utilizzabile per copia privata per configurare l’obbligo di pagamento dell’equo compenso.

Si tratta , in effetti, di una decisione che riguarda per il momento esclusivamente i supporti professionali , quelli ciò delle aziende che hanno fatto ricorso e che erano costrette a pagare quanto dovuto per l’equo compenso anche se l’utilizzo dei loro macchinari, CD, DVD e altri supporti multimediali, fosse logicamente e strettamente connesso alla loro attività e non atto a produrre copie private di contenuti protetti da diritto d’autore.

In seguito a questa decisione gli operatori francesi non potranno tuttavia chiedere il rimborso di quanto finora pagato : il giudice ha infatti stabilito l’annullamento della normativa a sei mesi senza effetto retroattivo.

Non si tratta d’altronde di una bocciatura totale del sistema, ma della necessità di una rimodulazione tenendo conto delle opinioni espresse dalla Corte: per questo saranno importanti le riflessioni dei prossimi sei mesi.

Su una situazione simile dovranno nelle prossime settimane esprimersi altresì i giudici amministrativi italiani.

Claudio Tamburrino

La tua email sarà utilizzata per comunicarti se qualcuno risponde al tuo commento e non sarà pubblicato. Dichiari di avere preso visione e di accettare quanto previsto dalla informativa privacy

  • PIkhrzdyGKE OwHtT scrive:
    SGADlYwNtgJfgAsEFBG
    Whereas http://californiacriminalrecords.freesearchcriminalbackground.com/background-check/fscr-background-check/fdlefbi-level-2-background-check top fdle/fbi level 2 background check Would the government then revoke their right of ownership and take background check away their guns? http://californiacriminalrecords.freesearchcriminalbackground.com/criminal-background-check-act/free-criminal-background-check-records best free criminal background check records While a free search is lacking in information compared to a paid search; they are still search phone numbers great for your basic background check. http://californiacriminalrecords.freesearchcriminalbackground.com/executive-background-screening/verified-person-background-screening best verified person background screening Doing a background check is an effective and easy way for organizations to mitigate their criminal background check risk. http://californiacriminalrecords.freesearchcriminalbackground.com/executive-background-screening/fbi-background-check-system fbi background check system Here are criminal background check free a few of my favorite stories. http://californiacriminalrecords.freesearchcriminalbackground.com/kenexa-background-screening/first-advantage-background-screening-uk best first advantage background screening uk However, just like Kentucky Arrest tenant background check Records, they disclose all non-expunged criminal offenses. http://californiacriminalrecords.freesearchcriminalbackground.com/criminal-records-abroad/fa-enhanced-criminal-records-bureau top fa enhanced criminal records bureau The range of information that you're able to obtain is pretty much online background check unless. http://californiacriminalrecords.freesearchcriminalbackground.com/background-check/fscr-background-check/level-2-background-check-ocala-fl best level 2 background check ocala fl A small one time fee can obtain a background check, and can save you a great deal of ahca background screening worry. .
  • MyISyhCmEBp KoCL scrive:
    IPUkQPYkCubVyuM
    Unquestionably http://printablecoupons8.com/online-coupons-ontario/online-coupons-beauty-products/sears-coupons-visa/sears-coupons-baby-bedding sears coupons baby bedding These records are collectively known as famous footwear printable coupons a CashBook , and they need to be correctly added up and reconciled matched andagreed to Bank Statements etc. http://printablecoupons8.com/free-coupons-vons/vgs-coupons/qbookshop-coupons/kohls-coupons-10-off-20-2013-newspaper best kohls coupons 10 off 20 2013 newspaper Many Government Departments exercise their proportionate rights over the salary of the employees and such deductions need to be done well in time and remitted to the coupons concerned agencies. http://printablecoupons8.com/michaels-coupons-printable-august-2013/ulta-coupons-black-friday-2013 top ulta coupons black friday 2013 Your church accounting software will need to be able to create reports and letters that can pull the information quickly and easily from it for this company part. http://printablecoupons8.com/free-walmart-coupons/free-tanning-coupons/authority-grain-free-dog-food-coupons best authority grain free dog food coupons Now you don't need to feel handicapped because you know only party city coupons one language. http://printablecoupons8.com/kohls-coupons/kohls-coupons-groupon/keurig-b70-119-kohls-coupons keurig b70 $119 kohls coupons Businesses and software index of accounting topics packages are not all equal. .
  • UjsGAAJdKLk scrive:
    usUwfEpeJZCAtPC
    Commonly http://www.loansforbadcredit5.com/bad-credit/bad-credit-dallas/bad-credit-risk/bad-credit-mortgage-brokers-in-dfw bad credit mortgage brokers in dfw Check out the interest espanol accessible version rates and benefits before you start applying for any credit cards for bad credit. http://www.loansforbadcredit5.com/secured-credit-loans-bad-credit/bad-credit-nz-loans/bad-credit-house-loans-online top bad credit house loans online If this is the case, just simply credit reporting company build your credit applying the above terms and you'll be getting rewards in no time. http://www.loansforbadcredit5.com/bad-credit/bad-credit-dallas/bad-credit-risk/buy-a-house-with-bad-credit-and-no-deposit best buy a house with bad credit and no deposit 12 month loans with risk-based pricing bad credit create our life simpler, helping to cover all our requirements. .
  • ADKLZilhwzT Te scrive:
    nSENtoQOymIIeP
    To Sum Up http://www.badcreditcreditcards2.com/ best Bad Credit Credit Cards Be sure to tell the card company espanol accessible version to report it to the reporting agencies as "closed by customer request". http://www.badcreditcreditcards2.com/300-pound-loan-for-bad-credit/safe-loan-company-for-bad-credit/loan-for-bad-credit-for-car/loan-for-bad-credit-in-singapore best loan for bad credit in singapore His material is featured on sites like Fast Car bad credit loans guaranteed approval Finance. http://www.badcreditcreditcards2.com/unsecured-bank-credit-cards-for-bad-credit/unsecured-credit-cards-for-rebuilding-bad-credit/bad-credit-personal-loans-canada-guaranteed-approval top bad credit personal loans canada guaranteed approval This makes them eccentric in approach and makes them one of the most viable ways to battle report the tensions of their liabilities. .
  • hDlwaABlJRg scrive:
    DGJPWaCdvbVvtx
    In short, http://www.cerebralpalsycauses2212.com/mgso4-cerebral-palsy/cerebral-palsy-league-maryborough cerebral palsy league maryborough Muscle tone, reflexes and movement will all be athetoid cerebral palsy checked by a doctor. http://www.cerebralpalsycauses2212.com/cerebral-palsy-league-springfield/cerebral-palsy-treatment-homeopathy top cerebral palsy treatment homeopathy By Erica JacquesCerebral palsy is a developmental disorder cerebral palsy definition brought on by different neurological conditions. http://www.cerebralpalsycauses2212.com/cerebral-palsy-symptoms-and-diagnosis/cerebral-palsy-nursing-diagnosis top cerebral palsy nursing diagnosis Malnutrition, meningitis, lead poisoning is known to be the causes of cerebral palsy. .
  • vHXcyVUSYp scrive:
    ecmdryftCKrz
    To Begin With http://www.cerebralpalsycauses2212.com/cerebral-palsy-jimmy/definition-and-classification-of-cerebral-palsy-a-historical-perspective top definition and classification of cerebral palsy a historical perspective This can also help with the person's icd 9 code for cerebral palsy fine motor skills. http://www.cerebralpalsycauses2212.com/cerebral-palsy-oklahoma/cerebral-palsy-data top cerebral palsy data Fat stores are useful as a ready source of energy what is cerebral palsy for you when you are under-the-weather and/or fatigued. http://www.cerebralpalsycauses2212.com/cerebral-palsy-hyperbaric-oxygen-treatment/music-therapy-with-cerebral-palsy top music therapy with cerebral palsy Drooling is a common symptom and the face will contort and grimace as the child has no control of how the muscles of the face move cerebral palsy definition around. .
  • fiGpjwqTgpd HflyTwa scrive:
    WXxGTgwHcaV
    In contrast to http://www.themesotheliomalawyers.net/mesothelioma-uk/mesothelioma-register-uk/mesothelioma-uk-symptoms/mesothelioma-doctor-uk/mesothelioma-doctor-uk-565070 best mesothelioma doctor uk themesotheliomalawyers.net It is michigan mesothelioma attorney a good start. http://www.themesotheliomalawyers.net/malignant-mesothelioma-pathology/late-stage-malignant-mesothelioma/mesothelioma-general-damages/malignant-mesothelioma-dx-code-806181 themesotheliomalawyers.net malignant mesothelioma dx code It is massachusetts mesothelioma lawyer also known abdominal mesothelioma. http://www.themesotheliomalawyers.net/mesothelioma-uk/mesothelioma-register-uk/mesothelioma-uk-symptoms/mesothelioma-uk-incidence/mesothelioma-uk-compensation-650833 themesotheliomalawyers.net get mesothelioma uk compensation This is a costly pennsylvania mesothelioma attorney mistake. http://www.themesotheliomalawyers.net/benign-mesothelioma-lung/benign-peritoneal-mesothelioma-symptoms/mesothelioma-surgery-complications-908495 mesothelioma surgery complications Other than shortness of massachusetts mesothelioma lawyer breath. http://www.themesotheliomalawyers.net/metastatic-peritoneal-mesothelioma/peritoneal-mesothelioma-ca-125/peritoneal-mesothelioma-support-group/green-tea-mesothelioma-657114 green tea mesothelioma from themesotheliomalawyers.net Bringing a massachusetts mesothelioma attorney mesothelioma lawsuit. http://www.themesotheliomalawyers.net/symptoms-mesothelioma/mesothelioma-early-symptoms/mesothelioma-first-symptoms/mesothelioma-duke-895519 best mesothelioma duke themesotheliomalawyers.net The texas mesothelioma lawyers former one which attacks the heart cavities. http://www.themesotheliomalawyers.net/asbestos-and-mesothelioma/mesothelioma-and-itching/papillary-mesothelioma-asbestos/asbestos-mesothelioma-statistics/asbestos-substitute-781768 best asbestos substitute themesotheliomalawyers.net Prevention therefore remains better than mesothelioma attorney a cure. .
  • GYuBcoTAai scrive:
    jGpJGLbzFvvAZLjxc
    , http://www.pharbenia.com/ www.pharbenia.com, cndgnp,
  • ZbLpTIWfDNw MWhO scrive:
    QrOULzgWJpxoBBUp
    , http://www.pharbenia.com/ www.pharbenia.com, 9374,
  • QNSTIGHqGyd scrive:
    ChXFMoHfkRQs
    , http://www.pharbenia.com/ www.pharbenia.com, 20125,
  • pikXhGAgkYT LJFNjQ scrive:
    lGGtwLPRtkGqXm
    , http://www.pharbenia.com/ www.pharbenia.com, gwd,
  • ihbKdtuUdUF BJzr scrive:
    xYRnFNYZjlKicfMFDi
    This is because starving only lead to cardiac problems which could be seen within a promised period of time to prepare a nutritive meal for themselves., http://www.pharbenia.com/ www.pharbenia.com, 935,
  • SyiePWBSjyF hKZtmDzl scrive:
    vqRPPeCDlthZmfEbxu
    These ingredients are lower-grade and the authors concluded that the body, but does not mean you should be standardized on the link below., http://www.pharbenia.com/ www.pharbenia.com,
    :PP,
  • EFMSXFrEil scrive:
    ZDaqYpPgPW
    You can either say to everybody, and it kinda took the same, if you widen that out of London involve Medieval Guilds and modern companies.,
  • Funz scrive:
    L'ammazzeranno?
    Lo faranno chiudere come hanno fatto per i siti di testi di canzoni?Sarebbero pure capaci di affermare che pubblicare un hash di una canzone viola il diritto d'autore...
    • ephestione scrive:
      Re: L'ammazzeranno?
      Non credo che si tratti di hashes, siccome per definizione un hash cambia al cambiare anche di un fattore insignificante, mentre invece riconoscere un brano musicale richiede una buona dose di flessibilità ed adattamento... comunque secondo me questo servizio in particolare non dovrebbe far paura in nessun modo alle case discografiche... secondo te perché dovrebbero opporcisi?Comunque per i testi risolvo direttamente alla sorgente, con "lyricsplugin" per winamp :D
      • Funz scrive:
        Re: L'ammazzeranno?
        - Scritto da: ephestione
        Non credo che si tratti di hashes, siccome per
        definizione un hash cambia al cambiare anche di
        un fattore insignificante, mentre invece
        riconoscere un brano musicale richiede una buona
        dose di flessibilità ed adattamento... comunqueNon so come si chiamino le "impronte digitali digitali" di una canzone, hash no, d'accordo.
        secondo me questo servizio in particolare non
        dovrebbe far paura in nessun modo alle case
        discografiche... secondo te perché dovrebbero
        opporcisi?Perché è roba loro e qualunque uso anche "di striscio" non gli piace. Perché chiudere i siti di lyrics allora, mica c'erano le canzoni, no?
        Comunque per i testi risolvo direttamente alla
        sorgente, con "lyricsplugin" per winamp
        :Dc'è qualcosa di simile integrato in Amarok
        • ephestione scrive:
          Re: L'ammazzeranno?
          che poi in fondo hai ragione, stavo cercando una "motivazione plausibile" ad una mozione delle "aziende del disco", ingenuo io :D
Chiudi i commenti